Analysis
Which router VPNs have independent speed tests?
The publications listed do not allow us to confirm a list of independent speed tests for NordVPN, ExpressVPN, Surfshark and Proton VPN, or to name the fastest of them. A provider's test on a computer shows the performance of that connection; a test of a specific router additionally takes its hardware and firmware into account. When choosing a home VPN in the UK, these results need to be distinguished: app speed cannot automatically be transferred to a router.
5 min readUpdated Published by VPN for Devices
Connecting a router: what the instructions confirm
The official documentation helps you establish the method of connection. The existence of a setup document does not in itself confirm speed: for that, you need a publication of results describing the device, protocol and measurement conditions.
| Situation | Protocol | Connection method |
|---|---|---|
| Manual setup of a compatible router with CitadelVPN MAX | WireGuard or OpenVPN | Importing the configuration provided by the company; Keenetic is given as an example |
| Setting up Proton VPN on OpenWrt | WireGuard | According to the official instructions for OpenWrt |
| Manual connection of a router to Surfshark | WireGuard | According to the official instructions for manual setup |
Proton VPN has a document on OpenWrt and WireGuard, and Surfshark has a guide to manual WireGuard on a router. The titles of these pages confirm that instructions exist. Their applicability to your model should be established from the text of the document and the capabilities of the firmware.
Publications about providers: setup separately, results separately
What to look for with NordVPN, ExpressVPN, Surfshark and Proton VPN
NordVPN publishes a guide to choosing a router. Surfshark has a general guide to setting up a router, and Proton VPN has a guide to installing on a router. These are documents for checking the method of connection, so they cannot be used as the results of a speed comparison.
To include any of the four services, including ExpressVPN, in a list of those that have passed independent testing, a separate publication is needed: who carried out the measurement, when, on which device and what result was obtained. General protocol support likewise does not establish compatibility with a specific router.
We recommend separating two levels of evidence. At the first level is a provider's speed measurement with a specified device and conditions. At the second is a separate measurement on a router with a named model, firmware and client protocol. The first level is useful for assessing a service; the second is closer to the question of the speed of your home network.
What the AV-TEST report and the methodology pages provide
The AV-TEST comparative report from December 2022 should be read through its result tables and description of conditions. A single link to a report is not enough to attribute a result to a specific provider or to declare it the fastest on a router.
The published VPNTest.org methodology describes the measurement procedure. The existence of results for a particular service is confirmed by a separate publication of results. A methodology without such a publication gives no grounds for including a brand in a speed rating.
Independence also requires checking: look at who the authors of the measurements are, who commissioned the work and how the funding is disclosed. The presence of a detailed methodology does not in itself establish the independence of a publication.
Checking the report: what the speed was compared against
The baseline connection and measurement conditions
In the Secure-VPN methodology, the VPN result is compared with a clean connection measured immediately before it. Such an initial measurement is called a baseline. It allows you to assess the change in speed relative to the available channel at that moment.
For a reader in the UK, the location of the measurement matters in practice. A result on a different route does not promise the same download speed and latency at home. Download speed shows the rate at which data is received; latency is the response time. A high download speed on its own does not describe the responsiveness of a connection.
Which details make a result applicable
Look in the report for the measurement device, the point of connection, the protocol, the baseline speed, the download speed and the latency. For a separate router test, the model and firmware version are also needed. These are our criteria for assessing a publication, not a description of tests carried out by the editorial team.
Check whether the measurements were repeated across different sessions and whether the conditions remained the same: the server, the method of connection and the load on the home network. One successful measurement does not show the spread of results. At the same time, the absence of a device model in an article does not in itself prove that the author measured the speed on a computer or server.
Wording such as "fast VPN", "supports WireGuard" and "suitable for routers" does not replace results. To constitute proof, measurable indicators, a date and the conditions to which the conclusion applies are needed.
Home router: what to clarify before paying
The processor handles the VPN connection, so when assessing speed the hardware must be considered together with the protocol and firmware. The publications in question do not provide grounds to determine the speed limit of your router or to give it a hardware diagnosis. Before buying, establish the compatibility of the exact model and the availability of the required configuration.
For example, the owner of a compatible Keenetic obtains a WireGuard or OpenVPN configuration on CitadelVPN MAX and compares the connection with and without the VPN under identical conditions. For other devices, you can move on to the general choice of VPN by device.
Before buying, proceed step by step:
- Check the model, the firmware and support for the required protocol in client mode.
- Find the service's instructions and the conditions for obtaining a configuration. For manual setup, CitadelVPN specifies WireGuard and OpenVPN on MAX.
- For NordVPN, ExpressVPN, Surfshark and Proton VPN, look for separate publications of results with an author, a date, a device and conditions.
- Keep a provider's test separate from a router test. The publications in question do not allow us to name the fastest option for your home network.